Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Bayern Formations

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Originally posted by SuperBayern View Post
    Benatia is prone to making huge errors and rash decisions, such as that tackle he made against Aguero... Dante is a more experienced defender in terms of the Bundesliga and Champions League. He functions better in a 4-man defence and has a solid partnership with Boateng, provided there are adequate cover in defensive midfield.
    Dante is prone to mistakes and rash decisions just as much. Just saying.

    Comment


    • Number of mistakes Benatia has made at Bayern: 1

      Number of mistakes Dante has made at Bayern: I've seriously lost count

      Comment


      • Originally posted by Grey View Post
        Number of mistakes Benatia has made at Bayern: 1

        Number of mistakes Dante has made at Bayern: I've seriously lost count
        Just two questions:

        1) In how many games?
        2) In how many games?

        Comment


        • Originally posted by Blackroze View Post
          Just two questions:

          1) In how many games?
          2) In how many games?
          Not going to play this game because Dante's downturn happened in the 2013 CL final, having played an entire season (his first) nearly flawlessly. Can you name a single good game he's had since May of 2013? I can name quite a few good games that Benatia has had since then, and a couple of them were even in a Bayern jersey. Remember, Benatia has quite a lot of experience, most of which is positive, playing in a possession-based team with a high back line. Dante's only experience with this has come at Bayern with the introduction of Pep's tactics - and he's failed stupendously now for a season and a half straight.

          Comment


          • Are we seriously having the discussion of who's better between Benatia and Dante? REALLY?!

            Comment


            • Dante has proven himself in the bigger stages way more than Benatia. As far as I am concerned he is still higher in the hierarchy of Bayern.

              But that doesn't mean much, Benatia could easily surpass Dante in one successful season.

              Comment


              • Originally posted by rohr View Post
                Dante has proven himself in the bigger stages way more than Benatia. As far as I am concerned he is still higher in the hierarchy of Bayern.

                But that doesn't mean much, Benatia could easily surpass Dante in one successful season.
                Well, no. You just have to watch the 2 or 3 center-backs defenders of all big games :

                AS Roma (h): Benatia, Boateng
                AS Roma (a) : Benatia, Boateng
                Manchester City (h) : Benatia, Boateng
                Manchester City (a) : Benatia, Boateng
                CSKA (a) : Benatia, Dante
                CSKA (h) : Dante, Boateng (massive turn-over)
                Dortmund : Benatia, Boateng
                Schalke : Boateng, Badstuber (Benatia sign 2 days ago)
                Gladbach : Benatia, Dante (Boateng injury)
                Leverkusen : Benatia, Boateng
                Wolfsburg : Boateng, Badstuber, Dante (first game of season, Benatia is Roma player)

                In big games :

                Boateng : 9
                Benatia : 8
                Dante : 4
                Badstuber : 2 (and way more instead of Dante if he wasn't injured)

                Hierarchy is clear.

                Comment


                • Did Benatia win the CL?

                  Comment


                  • Originally posted by rohr View Post
                    Did Benatia win the CL?
                    Never mind the Champions League, Benatia has never won a single trophy in his professional career.

                    Comment


                    • Benatia has not been tested yet, it's easy to look good against the likes of Augsburg and Mainz, his first real test was against Man City and he failed instantly. We know that Benatia functions well in the Bundesliga but does he function well against the best players in the world in the CL? That remains to be seen.

                      Comment


                      • Ok we got two players that are gone now, are we hoping to get our injured players to be back or are we actually going to get some players?

                        Comment


                        • Originally posted by St3ph3n View Post
                          Ok we got two players that are gone now, are we hoping to get our injured players to be back or are we actually going to get some players?
                          Bayern aren't planning to buy anyone in January unless a very serious injury occurs.

                          Badstuber and Alaba will return to the team in the coming few days.

                          Martinez, Thiago and Lahm will all hopefully return between February and March if all goes well.

                          Comment


                          • Originally posted by Springbok51 View Post
                            Bayern aren't planning to buy anyone in January unless a very serious injury occurs.

                            Badstuber and Alaba will return to the team in the coming few days.

                            Martinez, Thiago and Lahm will all hopefully return between February and March if all goes well.
                            Bleh, I was hoping for at least one player.
                            New things always shines nice (at least for a few days )

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by rohr View Post
                              Did Benatia win the CL?
                              Did Dante win anything important before coming to Bayern ?

                              No. And he was more important than Van Buyten who won 3 Bundesliga and played two UCL finals.

                              Open your eyes, Benatia is better than Dante like Dante was better than VB !!

                              Comment


                              • Originally posted by jbm View Post
                                Are we seriously having the discussion of who's better between Benatia and Dante? REALLY?!
                                Well there's nothing else to discuss when there's no Bundesliga.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X