Announcement

Collapse
No announcement yet.

Bayern Formations

Collapse
X
 
  • Filter
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts

  • Originally posted by Giovane View Post
    The man that wrote that must be kinda crazy.

    However, your argumentation is kinda non existant.
    I'm not

    Of course my argumentation is existant.

    4-2-3-1 always worked in Bayern, not 4-3-3 or else.
    Our squad is build for that, even more if Sanchez is loaned.

    Comment


    • Originally posted by FernandoBR View Post
      And screw Müller right ?
      Why you keep bitching about everything!!!! The man merely expressed his desire and what he wished for...no one forces you to not put muller in your preferred line-up.

      He included griezmann, you include muller, case closed!!!!

      Comment


      • Ancelotti : "We have a lot of possibility in midfield. Tolisso, Vidal, Rudy, Thiago and also Martinez can interpret the position differently and play in that position. There is no secret, the plan is to play 2 central-midfielders".

        He gave this list of 5 players and say we'll play with 2 CM. Obviously this 5 players will be the possible 2 CM.

        No Renato Sanches listed by the way. Clearly out and not wanted by the coach and Bayern.

        Comment


        • So 4-2-3-1 it is then. We need another winger then.

          Comment


          • Yeah if we really are going to rely heavily on wingers in a 4-2-3-1 then it would have been nice to get another winger, even better one that can back up ST. Not that James isn't a great transfer in general. Apparently we are not though. Alas sometimes things don't work out and it is frustrating often.

            Though I don't think any of this transfer anxiety would be as bad if it weren't for all of the frustration/falling short from the last several years finally coming to a head. Pressure is escalated.

            I'm kind of surprised Carlo spelled out so early he plans to use 2 CMs. I'd still have to think we'll see some experimentation with that otherwise. I suppose Muller or James could be used to fill in on the RW as to not always rely on Robben. Coman has played the right before as well. Should be interesting. At very least I hope if we're going to use a 4-2-3-1 we'll see James in the hole a lot. Def want to see him working magic with Muller and Lewy somehow too. Those 3 playing off of and creating for each other.

            Comment


            • With Robben and Ribery's injury proneness we seem awfully short up front for a 4-2-3-1. Essentially 6 players for the 4 attacking positions, we need definitely need another winger as well in my opinion.

              Carlo also added today that Martinez will play in defense and only in midfield in emergency situations. This means that our attackers will have to do a lot of defensive work, don't see that working with the guys we have.

              So likely we'll line up like:

              Neuer/Ulreich
              Kimmich/Rafinha - Boateng/Martinez - Hummels/Sule - Alaba/Bernat
              Vidal/Tolisso/Sanches - Thiago/Rudy/Sanches
              Robben/Mueller - James/Mueller - Ribery/Coman
              Lewandowski/Mueller

              Comment


              • I still want to see the Christmas tree:

                Neuer

                Kimmich - Boateng - Hummels - Alaba

                Vidal - Thiago - Tolisso

                Muller - James
                Lewa


                Robben if healthy and performing well can start ahead of Muller or James (depending on their forms)

                Comment


                • Originally posted by mea95 View Post
                  I still want to see the Christmas tree:

                  Neuer

                  Kimmich - Boateng - Hummels - Alaba

                  Vidal - Thiago - Tolisso

                  Muller - James
                  Lewa


                  Robben if healthy and performing well can start ahead of Muller or James (depending on their forms)
                  Roosoo will agree with me, I fundamentally don't understand why anyone would want to see another formation than this one. There is still a healthy amount of wiggle room too, like swapping Muller/James for Robben, or swapping Tolisso/Vidal for Martinez. There's no question, this formation fits our strengths the best.

                  Comment


                  • The fact I didn't see this formation being deployed in the last friendlies was the main reason of my being upset about said matches.

                    Comment




                    • This. Nothing else. Because it is the best.

                      But we'll have some Tolisso, Vidal, Thiago midfield and some Ribéry, Lewandowski, Müller attack.

                      Amazing ...

                      Comment


                      • The club needs to hire a team, 3 to 4 people, to follow all the fan message boards and at the end of each week present management with the collective opinions being expressed on topics such as

                        Formations / starting 11

                        Transfer targets / signings

                        Views of players abilities and attributes from week to week.

                        The manager can focus on game plans within the chosen formation and starting line up, and deal with in game decisions and subs.

                        That way the fans collectively get what the majority wants, and when the team fails there would be less bitching, and when they win the fans can take more ownership in the success as most got what they wanted.

                        Fan relation problem solved.

                        Spoiler
                        its so frustrating having so many agree on the main starting 11 and formation that best fits our current talent and still seeing the players and their abilities mismanaged by the current manager.


                        Perhaps RBL could be a place for such social experiments.

                        #smarterthanthemanager

                        Comment


                        • Originally posted by FreeBird View Post
                          The club needs to hire a team, 3 to 4 people, to follow all the fan message boards and at the end of each week present management with the collective opinions being expressed on topics such as

                          Formations / starting 11

                          Transfer targets / signings

                          Views of players abilities and attributes from week to week.

                          The manager can focus on game plans within the chosen formation and starting line up, and deal with in game decisions and subs.

                          That way the fans collectively get what the majority wants, and when the team fails there would be less bitching, and when they win the fans can take more ownership in the success as most got what they wanted.

                          Fan relation problem solved.

                          Spoiler
                          its so frustrating having so many agree on the main starting 11 and formation that best fits our current talent and still seeing the players and their abilities mismanaged by the current manager.


                          Perhaps RBL could be a place for such social experiments.

                          #smarterthanthemanager
                          This exists..somewhat!

                          TC Freisenbruch using online voting to pick the team and decide transfers - ESPN FC

                          Comment


                          • Played the fifa 18 demo yesterday

                            Played Real Madrid with

                            Neuer
                            Kimmich - Süle - Hummels - Alaba
                            Thiago - Rudy - Vidal
                            James - Müller
                            Lewandowski

                            and won 5-0. Then played them again with:

                            Neuer
                            Kimmich - Boateng - Hummels - Alaba
                            Thiago - Vidal
                            Robben - James - Coman
                            Lewandowski

                            and lost 2-1.

                            4321 pls Carlo

                            Comment


                            • Originally posted by DanaSchofield View Post
                              Played the fifa 18 demo yesterday

                              Played Real Madrid (in extra easy mode) with

                              Neuer
                              Kimmich - Süle - Hummels - Alaba
                              Thiago - Rudy - Vidal
                              James - Müller
                              Lewandowski

                              and won 5-0. Then played them again (in extremly hard mode) with:

                              Neuer
                              Kimmich - Boateng - Hummels - Alaba
                              Thiago - Vidal
                              Robben - Müller - Ribéry
                              Lewandowski

                              and lost 2-1.

                              4231 pls Carlo
                              Fixed

                              Comment


                              • looking at rudy's performance from last night, this guy should be getting a lots of minutes on the field. as of now, vidal and thiago are the undisputed starters and after them comes rudy.

                                as for ribery, ribery should be benched 90% of the games. robben on the other hand, at his best he's a level or two above every other player in our team, even at his current age.

                                year after year, robben keeps reminding us how unique and elite he truly is. always our best and most dangerous player whenever we face the strongest teams. last year, him and vidal were level above anyone else. the year before, he destoryed juventus single-handedly before suffering season-ending injury, and as a result, our attack never looked the same afterwards.

                                if he's fit and ready, robben should always start in the big games.

                                Comment

                                Working...
                                X